Karl Marx summed up Communism as “from each according to his ability,to each according to his needs.” This is a good,pithy saying,which,in practice,has succeeded in bringing,upon those under its sway,misery,poverty,rape,torture,slavery,and death.
For the saying implies but does not name the effective agency of its supposed utopia. The agency is called “The State,” and the motto,fleshed out,for the benefit of the easily confused must read “The State will take from each according to his ability: the State will give to each according to his needs.” “Needs and abilities” are,of course,subjective. So the operative statement may be reduced to “the State shall take,the State shall give.”
All of us have had dealings with the State,and have found,to our chagrin,or,indeed,terror,that we were not dealing with well-meaning public servants or even with ideologues but with overworked,harried bureaucrats. These,as all bureaucrats,obtain and hold their jobs by complying with directions and suppressing the desire to employ initiative,compassion,or indeed,common sense. They are paid to follow orders.
Rule by bureaucrats and functionaries is an example of the first part of the Marxist equation:that the Government shall determine the individual’s abilities.
As rules by the Government are one-size-fits-all,any governmental determination of an individual’s abilities must be based on a bureaucratic assessment of the lowest possible denominator. The government,for example,has determined that black people (somehow) have fewer abilities than white people,and,so,must be given certain preferences. Anyone acquainted with both black and white people knows this assessment is not only absurd but monstrous. And yet it is the law.
Read more at The Daily Beast. By David Mamet.